Do you know how frustrating it is to work really hard at something for months or even years, only to have almost nothing to show for it?
I see this all the time with people I work with. Some are trying to lose fat, but the scale won't budge. Others are desperately trying to get out of pain, but nothing they do seems to make a meaningful difference.
And there's a common thread between them: they're putting plenty of effort into solving the wrong problem.
It's an enormously important problem to solve because if you don't figure out what actually needs to change, you can spend years spinning your wheels. In some cases, the rest of your life.
You want examples? It's your lucky day. I brought examples.
Take Sam, age 42.
He's a freaking beast who loves lifting heavy, and he enjoys running because it helps him manage stress. The problem? He needs to lose 50 pounds.
He lifts 3-5 times per week for 75-90 minutes, benches 275+, squats 365+, and runs three times per week for 30-45 minutes.
He's putting in plenty of work. But he's neglecting the one thing that would make the biggest difference: consistently eating fewer calories than he burns.
Between the snacking and drinking, he's eating at maintenance or in a slight surplus most days. So the scale never moves. He tries really hard for a few months, sees little to no progress, and eventually decides his metabolism must be slow because of genetics or because he's getting older. Then he gives up.
And those 50 pounds stick around, or worse, he gains even more. Frick.
Then there's Jim, age 55.
He's dealing with chronic knee pain, and he's tried everything. Literally everything.
He's cut out sugar and seed oils, he's taking peptides, and he's stopped running and lifting for six months. Surely that's enough time to recover and get back to doing what he loves, right?
Except he's never addressed the thing that would actually help: progressively rebuilding his knee's capacity through appropriate loading, consistently, over time.
When he does try to get back to being active, he doesn't adjust the workload to something his knee can tolerate. Instead, he bounces between doing too little, which allows his strength and capacity to decline, and doing too much, which flares his symptoms right back up.
He repeats this cycle for years until he eventually decides his knees are just shot, bro. They're done. He's got no choice but to wait for a knee replacement. Frick.
The cost of all this is brutal.
Sam never loses the weight. Jim never gets back to the activities he loves. Both spend years frustrated with their bodies, convinced there's nothing they can do about it.
Absolutely heartbreaking, right?
But there's an even bigger cost that I think gets overlooked: repeated attempts and failures slowly shape the way you see yourself.
When you try to lose fat or get out of pain for a few weeks without much progress, you might think, "I've got to try something else," or "Maybe I'm just not trying hard enough." But when you repeat that cycle for years, something changes. You start telling yourself a different story. That your metabolism is broken or your knees are just bad, and that this is simply how things are going to be from now on.
Eventually, you stop looking for solutions altogether because you've convinced yourself there aren't any.
And you spend the rest of your life living smaller than you needed to.
Frick that!
What to do this week
Before you put more effort into reaching a goal, take a step back and make sure you're putting that effort in the right place.
Here's a simple exercise:
Write down everything you're currently doing to reach your goal.
Circle the ONE thing that would make the biggest difference if you did it consistently.
Ask yourself whether you're really, truly, honestly doing that thing consistently.
Not whether you're doing something related to it or whether you're doing a bunch of other things that might help around the edges. Are you consistently addressing the biggest obstacle standing between you and your goal?
If not, start there.
Getting your effort pointed in the right direction
There's a common misconception that people who hire personal trainers are lazy. That they need someone to hold their hand, keep them accountable, and make sure they actually put in the work.
I couldn't disagree more!
Almost every single one of my clients is an incredibly hard worker. The problem is that they've often spent months or years putting that effort into things that aren't moving them closer to their goals.
That's where I believe coaching provides its greatest value. My number one job is to help you figure out what needs to change, take all that effort you're already willing to put in, and direct it toward the things that matter most.
The result? More progress, less guesswork, and often a whole lot less effort than you thought it would take.
Who wouldn't want that?!
If you'd like some help figuring out where your effort is best spent, fill out the 60-second coaching application form below:
P.S. You may have noticed I haven’t sent as many newsletters as usual the past few months.
Up there I said “Take Sam, age 42” and “Then there's Jim, age 55”, but I could’ve also said “Take John, age 30.” Aka, I’m also guilty of working on the wrong things.
The truth is, my newsletter list is still relatively small (around 300 people), and publishing more articles hasn't done much to grow it. Meanwhile, I've got around 2,300 followers on Instagram, and that's where I've been putting more of my energy lately. I'm focusing on growing that audience and getting my message in front of more people.
So if you haven't already, come find me over on Instagram!
I’ll still keep in touch here, it just won’t be as frequent as before.
Thanks for being here, thanks for your support, and have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
Best,
John
P.P.S. Some of you are like, “Thank God I haven’t had to look at a pic of this guy’s freaking dog in a few weeks”, and others are like “Where the puppy pics at??”
So, I’m sorry and you’re welcome.
3 Steps You Can Take
Apply for coaching - If you’re ready to start, you can fill out a coaching application here (it takes 90 seconds or less). Best case, you change your life. Worst case, I’ll help you draw up a road map to get closer to your goals.
Sign up for my newsletter - If you’d like to hear more, sign up for my mailing list here.
Keep learning - You can check out my other articles here. Nobody asked me to, but I’ve spent a ton of time researching everything from artificial sweeteners to saturated fat to testosterone and more, so you don’t have to.